
As usual if you’ve been following the Heaven Kneads journey, you know I’m all about getting back to the basics—real ingredients, fresh-milled grains, and zero shortcuts.
In Part 1, I covered the “Everything” dough that I like to use for quick sandwich breads or rolls. Now, we’re moving to the most common staple in the Italian kitchen and probably one I enjoy the most: Fresh Egg Pasta.
Why Fresh? (My Stand Against “Enriched”)
One of the biggest reasons I started making my own pasta was to get away from enriched flours. Honestly, pasta is an absolute staple in my diet and is made almost daily in my home in one way or another.
As I was changing my diet through my autoimmune journey, the grocery stores were beyond disappointing. The amount of pasta labeled an “enriched macaroni product” was overwhelming. Almost every single one is made with flour that’s been stripped of its nutrients and “enriched” with synthetic vitamins. In my home and microbakery, we just don’t need that. Whether you’re using organic all-purpose or fresh-milled durum wheat, I find this a significantly better option than store-bought. When you control the flour, you control the nutrition – and I wasn’t giving up pasta. I simply love my “Sunday gravy” too much.

The Recipe: The 2+1 Gold Standard
This isn’t your average water-and-flour dough. We’re using a specific ratio of fats to make this dough silky, strong, and deeply golden. You can use your hands with a fork and bench scraper with this recipe, or a stand mixer with a hook attachment.
- 2 Cups Organic AP Flour (or 250-260g Fresh-Milled Durum)
- 2 Whole Eggs+ 1 Egg Yolk (richness and color)
- 1/2 tsp Sea Salt
- 1/2 tbsp Beef Tallow (melted) or Avocado Oil
The beef tallow is my “signature” move. It’s something I tried out of curiosity when I wanted to avoid seed oils. It gives the pasta a nice savory depth, but avocado oil works well if you prefer a more mild taste.
Making the Dough
- The Volcano: Mound your flour and salt on a clean counter. Use a bowl or your hand to make a wide, deep well in the center. You want high walls so your eggs don’t breach the “dam.”
- The Center: Drop your 2 eggs, the extra yolk, and your tallow/oil into the well.
- The Whisk: Use a fork to beat the eggs and fat in the center. Slowly—very slowly—start whisking in flour from the inner walls of your volcano. Once it turns into a thick, custard-like paste, use a bench scraper or your hands to fold the rest of the flour in.
- Aly’s Tip: Some days, I have arthritis issues in my hands and the “well” method is a bit much. I’ve used a standard mixer with a dough hook before. I just whisk the eggs first and add them slowly to the flour “well” I’ve made around the hook. It works just as well!
- The Knead: This is the most important part. You need to knead this for 8-10 minutes. It will start out shaggy and maybe a bit dry, but keep going. You’re looking for a dough that is smooth, elastic, and doesn’t stick to your hands. If you’re using fresh-milled durum, it’s thirstier than store-bought flour; if it’s too crumbly to stay together, add a tiny spritz of water.
- The Rest: Wrap it tight in plastic or a damp cloth and let it sit for at least 30 minutes. If you try to roll it now, the gluten will be too tight and it’ll just shrink back.
- Roll, Cut, Boil: Using a pasta machine, roll out your pasta as desired and cut as needed. Boil in salted water 2-4 minutes or until pasta floats to top.
Hand-Cut Creativity: No Machine Required
You don’t need equipment to make world-class pasta. In fact, doing it by hand gives it a rustic texture that holds sauce better.
- The Roll: Use a heavy rolling pin to roll the dough out until it’s translucent. You should be able to see the shadow of your hand through it.
- The Fold & Cut: Generously dust your sheet of dough with flour so it doesn’t stick. Fold it over itself loosely a few times to create a flat “log.”
- The Knife: Use a sharp knife to slice the log into strips. Cut them thin for linguine, wider for fettuccine, or thick for pappardelle. Shake the nests out immediately so they don’t stick together.
- Be Creative: You don’t have to make long pasta like fettucine. You can cut the dough into squares for hand-pinched farfalle (bowties) or even use a crinkle cutter for something different. There are no rules here.
Saving it for Later
The best part about this dough? You can prep it ahead of time.
- To Freeze: Toss your cut noodle “nests” in a little extra flour, lay them on a baking sheet to flash-freeze for an hour, then toss them into a freezer bag.
- Don’t Thaw: When you’re ready to eat, drop them straight from the freezer into the boiling water. They’ll taste just as fresh as the day you made them.
The Cook
Fresh pasta is lightning fast. Drop it into heavily salted boiling water. It usually takes 2 to 4 minutes max. In my experience, as soon as they float to the top, they are ready to be tossed in your favorite sauce.

Heaven Kneads 2+1 Pasta: A Scratch-Made Essential Part 2
Recipe by

Servings
2-3 servings

Prep time
15 min
rest
30 min
cook time
2-4 min
This is not the “enriched macaroni products” from the store. This is real pasta—the kind that fueled generations of Italian kitchens. By using fresh-milled durum (or organic AP) and swapping standard oil for beef tallow, we’re creating a nutrient-dense noodle with a silky, savory “snap.” The extra yolk is our secret for that deep, heritage gold color and perfect elasticity. Whether you’re rolling by hand or using a machine, I hope this recipes encourages you and is a great addition to your table!
Ingredients
- 250-260g Fresh-Milled Durum (or 2 Cups Organic AP)
- 2 Eggs + 1 Egg Yolk
- 1/2 tsp Sea Salt
- 1/2 tbsp Beef Tallow (melted) or Avocado Oil
Directions
- Mound & Well: On a clean surface, mound your flour and salt. Create a wide, deep “volcano” well in the center with sturdy walls.
- Combine: Add eggs, yolk, and tallow into the center.
- Aly’s Tip: If using a stand mixer, whisk eggs first and add slowly to the flour around the dough hook.
- The Whisk: Use a fork to whisk the liquids, gradually pulling flour from the inner walls until a thick paste forms.
- The Knead: Fold in the remaining flour and knead by hand for 8–10 minutes. The dough should transform from shaggy/dry to smooth, supple, and elastic.
- The Rest: Wrap tightly in plastic or a damp cloth. Let sit at room temperature for at least 30 minutes to relax the gluten.
- Roll & Cut: * Machine: Roll to desired thickness and cut.
- Hand: Roll until translucent, flour the sheet, roll into a “log,” and slice with a sharp knife.
- The Cook: Drop into a large pot of “ocean-salty” boiling water. Cook for 2–4 minutes. When they float, they’re done!
Notes
If using fresh milled durum, keep a small spray bottle of water nearby or lightly dampen your hands while kneading – sometimes when my dough feels too “sandy”, this will help the dough come together.

Leave a Comment